“We want this to go viral.” It’s said at briefings with the same casual confidence with which one might say “we want the event to be successful” or “we want the product to sell well” — as if virality were a predictable outcome that results from the correct combination of effort, cleverness, and intent. As if there were a recipe. As if the agencies and brands that spent the most on “viral” content and got the least viral return had simply not tried hard enough, or hadn’t had the right insight, or had executed the wrong format. As if any of this were as controllable as a media buy.
The viral brief is perhaps the purest expression of magical thinking in the marketing industry. It asks for an outcome — massive organic distribution, cultural relevance, millions of unpaid impressions — that is by definition outside the control of anyone who briefs or produces it, then frames the request as a creative objective rather than as the statistical anomaly it actually is. And the creative or agency on the receiving end of this brief is put in an impossible position: explain the reality (which sounds like defeatism) or accept the brief as stated (which commits them to delivering something they cannot reliably deliver).
What Virality Actually Is
Viral content is content that spreads faster than it’s seeded — where the organic sharing multiplies the initial distribution beyond what the original publisher created or paid for. By this definition, virality is a measurement, not a quality. Content that goes viral has the quality of spreadability: something about it motivates people who encounter it to share it with others. That motivation can come from many sources — humor, outrage, utility, beauty, novelty, emotional resonance, social currency (sharing it makes me look good) — but it is always a property that the audience confers, not one that the creator installs.
This distinction — between the qualities that make content more or less spreadable and the act of spreading itself — is the gap that the viral brief ignores. You can study the characteristics of content that has spread widely. You can try to create content that has those characteristics. You can optimize distribution so that more people have the opportunity to encounter it. None of this guarantees virality, because virality is an emergent phenomenon that depends on cultural moment, competitive noise, platform algorithm behavior, and a degree of luck that no brief can eliminate.
The Virality Graveyard
For every piece of content that went unexpectedly viral, there are thousands of pieces of content that were explicitly designed to go viral and didn’t. Large budgets. Famous talent. Professional production. High-quality creative execution. Strategically launched on the right platform at the right time. And then: a few thousand views, a polite press release, and quiet disappointment. The virality graveyard is enormous and mostly invisible, because the postmortems of failed viral campaigns don’t get written up in trade publications the way the success stories do.
This survivorship bias is one reason the viral brief persists despite all available evidence that it’s based on a flawed model of how content spreads. The campaigns that went viral are visible and celebrated. The campaigns that were designed to go viral and didn’t are invisible. The client watching the successes believes that virality is achievable with the right creative thinking. The agency that produced the successes knows, usually, that a significant element of luck was involved — but rarely says so, because “we got lucky” is not a compelling creative credentials story.
What to Say When the Brief Says “Go Viral”
The honest response to the viral brief is to reframe the objective. Not to dismiss the ambition — large-scale organic distribution is a legitimate and valuable marketing outcome — but to translate it into something that can actually be designed for. Instead of “go viral,” the objective becomes “create content that maximizes shareability for our specific audience in our specific channel context.” That objective can be researched, designed toward, and measured against. Virality cannot.
This reframe also requires an honest conversation about what “viral” would actually look like for this brand in this context. A B2B software company and a consumer snack brand have different definitions of “massive organic distribution.” The B2B campaign that generates 50,000 organic views from decision-makers in the right industry is more valuable than the consumer campaign that generates 5 million views from people who will never buy the product. Virality without audience specificity is not a marketing strategy; it’s a vanity metric with extra steps.
And as we’ve argued repeatedly — from the results report to the awards paradox — the gap between impressive-looking numbers and actual business impact is where most marketing failures hide. A viral video that doesn’t move product isn’t a marketing success. It’s an entertaining footnote. The brief that recognizes this distinction produces better work than the one that chases the metric.
The One Thing That Actually Increases Shareability
If there’s one consistent finding across the research on organic content spread, it’s this: people share content that they feel reflects well on them, or that they believe their specific audience will genuinely value. Not content that is clever in the abstract, or well-produced in the generic sense, or funny to the average person. Content that speaks to a specific community, in a language that community recognizes, about something that community genuinely cares about.
This is the opposite of content designed to appeal to everyone. Content designed to appeal to everyone appeals, reliably, to nobody enough to share. Content designed for a specific someone — a real community with real characteristics and real interests — gets shared within that community with an intensity that broad-appeal content never achieves. The audience that says “this is exactly for people like us” is the audience that shares. That’s not a viral strategy. It’s an honesty strategy. Which turns out to be more effective, and considerably less magical.
Just received a brief that says “we want this to go viral”? Visit our shop before responding. Some purchases require a deep breath first.
